Utah Supreme Court Justice Hagen Resigns Amid Redistricting Conduct Probe
Justice Diana Hagen resigned from the Utah Supreme Court effective immediately on May 8, 2026 amid a probe into her conduct in a high-profile redistricting case.
The move follows her ex-husband's complaint alleging an inappropriate relationship with redistricting attorney David Reymann, a preliminary inquiry by the Utah Judicial Conduct Commission that did not lead to formal charges, and Hagen's statement that she stopped participating in the redistricting litigation in October 2024 and recused from Reymann-related matters in May 2025. Governor Spencer Cox will now name her successor on the court.
The episode traces back to reforms voters approved in 2018 creating an independent redistricting commission and to the Republican-controlled legislature's 2021 redraw, after it passed S.B. 200 removing a ban on gerrymandering and adopted its own maps. The League of Women Voters sued in 2022, represented by Reymann, and the Utah Supreme Court on July 11, 2024 unanimously ruled the legislature could not substantially impair voter initiatives, a decision that led to further trials and map revisions struck down in 2025. On February 20, 2026 the court dismissed the legislature's appeal and enforced a court-ordered map for the 2026 elections.
Coverage has shifted from legal analysis of the redistricting dispute to questions about judicial conduct and public confidence after the complaint and leaked messages surfaced. Conservatives and online critics celebrated Hagen's resignation and urged undoing the disputed maps, while officials note the Judicial Conduct Commission declined formal action before her departure.
The mainstream summary frames Justice Hagen's resignation primarily as a response to a complaint from her ex-husband regarding an alleged inappropriate relationship with redistricting attorney David Reymann. However, social media insights reveal a more charged narrative, with conservative figures like @EricLDaugh and @GuntherTheEagIe suggesting that Hagen's conduct was directly linked to partisan outcomes in the redistricting process, portraying her resignation as a necessary corrective to judicial corruption. They argue that her relationship with Reymann compromised her judicial integrity, which they claim led to a loss of Republican representation in Congress.
Moreover, the summary does not address the broader implications of Hagen's resignation in the context of public trust in the judiciary. A report from the Annenberg Public Policy Center highlights a significant decline in trust towards the federal judiciary, attributed to perceptions of partisanship and politicized judicial appointments. This context suggests that Hagen's case may be part of a larger trend of declining confidence in judicial impartiality, which is not captured in the mainstream narrative focused solely on her individual conduct and the immediate implications for redistricting in Utah.
Show source details & analysis (1 source)
📊 Relevant Data
On February 20, 2026, the Utah Supreme Court dismissed the state legislature's appeal in the League of Women Voters of Utah v. Utah State Legislature case, upholding a lower court ruling that struck down the 2021 congressional map as a partisan gerrymander and enforcing a court-ordered map for the 2026 elections.
Utah Supreme Court rejects Legislature's redistricting appeal — Utah News Dispatch
📌 Key Facts
- Justice Diana Hagen resigned from the Utah Supreme Court effective immediately, as reported May 8, 2026.
- Her resignation follows a probe triggered by her ex-husband's complaint alleging an "inappropriate" relationship with redistricting attorney David Reymann.
- The Utah Judicial Conduct Commission conducted a preliminary investigation and decided not to pursue formal action.
- Hagen said she stopped participating in the redistricting case in October 2024 and recused from all matters involving Reymann in May 2025.
- Gov. Spencer Cox is now responsible for naming Hagen's successor to the Utah Supreme Court.
📰 Source Timeline (1)
Follow how coverage of this story developed over time