Abortion and First Amendment

The Supreme Court will decide whether New Jersey Attorney General Matthew Platkin can compel First Choice, a pro‑life crisis pregnancy center, to turn over donor names, contact information and employment records—a subpoena the center calls a First Amendment and privacy invasion and a “fishing expedition.” Oral arguments are set for Dec. 2, 2025 at 10 a.m. ET, with the ACLU and pro‑life lawyers backing First Choice while state lawyers defend broad investigatory authority (saying compliance is voluntary or the scope can be narrowed) after Platkin formed a post‑Dobbs “strike force” and warned about crisis pregnancy centers.