Half Of California DAs Sue Newsom Over Mass Death Row Clemency
Nearly half of California's elected district attorneys and more than two dozen victims' families have asked a court to block Gov. Gavin Newsom's sweeping plan to commute every death sentence in the state, arguing he acted illegally and without warning to those most affected.[1]
In a 58-page petition filed Monday, November 16, in California state court, 29 DAs joined with families of murder and arson victims to challenge what they describe as Newsom's "eleventh-hour" bid to convert all 548 death row sentences to life terms, saying he skipped legally required notice to prosecutors and victims before issuing mass clemency.[1] The filing, authored by former Sacramento County district attorney Anne Marie Schubert and the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, warns that once death sentences are commuted, condemned inmates could try to win release or reduced terms by invoking other recent criminal justice reforms.[1]
Schubert's petition highlights families from some of the state's most notorious cases, including relatives of 12-year-old kidnapping and murder victim Polly Klaas and victims of the Esperanza Fire, a 2006 Riverside County blaze that killed five firefighters.[1] Under California law, governors can commute sentences but must provide notice and, in some cases, seek input from the state Supreme Court, and the plaintiffs argue that whatever Newsom's broader opposition to capital punishment, he cannot nullify hundreds of jury verdicts in one stroke without following those procedural rules.[1]
California has not executed anyone in roughly two decades, yet it still holds the country's largest death row, a gap that has fueled political battles over whether de facto abolition should be formalized or reversed.[1] Newsom imposed a moratorium on executions soon after taking office and has framed capital punishment as racially biased and costly, while voters have narrowly upheld the death penalty in statewide ballot measures, leaving the system in limbo.[1] Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra is expected to keep the execution moratorium in place, meaning no executions were likely even without commutations, but prosecutors say changing the sentences still matters because it affects future parole eligibility and resentencing options.[1]
The clash has spilled into national politics, with White House officials, including President Donald Trump, preparing to meet some of the victims' families about the clemency plan and a spokeswoman accusing Newsom of "refusing to carry out justice" for the state's most heinous crimes.[1] Supporters of Newsom's approach argue that ending death row aligns California with other states moving away from executions and spares victims' families decades of appeals, but the new lawsuit crystallizes a competing view: that any mass commutation must happen through voters or the legislature, not by a single governor acting at the close of his term.[1]
Show source details & analysis (1 source)
📌 Key Facts
- On Monday, November 16, 2026, a petition was filed on behalf of 29 California district attorneys and more than two dozen victims' families challenging Gov. Gavin Newsom's plan to commute all 548 death row sentences.
- The 58-page filing, authored by former Sacramento DA Anne Marie Schubert and the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, argues Newsom unlawfully issued eleventh-hour, en masse commutations without statutorily required notice to victims and prosecutors.
- Petitioners include families tied to cases such as the murder of Polly Klaas and the Esperanza Fire killings, and the lawsuit contends commutations would open the door for condemned inmates to seek release under other criminal justice reforms.
- California has not carried out an execution in roughly 20 years but still has the country’s largest death row, and Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra is expected to maintain a moratorium on executions.
- White House officials, including President Donald Trump, are expected to meet with some victims’ families about the clemency plan, and a spokeswoman criticized Newsom for "refusing to carry out justice" against death row inmates.
📰 Source Timeline (1)
Follow how coverage of this story developed over time