Fifth Circuit Invalidates Pregnant Workers Law Over Proxy Voting
A sharply divided federal appeals court on Friday invalidated the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act for Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi, ruling that Congress violated the Constitution when it relied on proxy voting to pass the law during the Covid-19 pandemic.[1]
In a 9-8 decision, the full US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit held that lawmakers who voted remotely under House pandemic rules could not be counted toward the quorum the Constitution requires for Congress to conduct business, effectively halting new workplace accommodation protections for an estimated 20 million women in the three states while litigation continues.[1] The ruling is expected to be appealed quickly to the Supreme Court, with the Biden administration warning that leaving it in place would disrupt federal employment law and invite challenges to other statutes approved using proxy procedures.[1]
Congress adopted proxy voting rules in 2020 as Covid-19 tore through Washington, allowing members of the House to authorize colleagues to cast votes on their behalf so that legislation could move even when many were quarantining or reluctant to travel.[1] The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, which requires most employers to provide reasonable accommodations for pregnancy and related conditions, was enacted against that backdrop as part of a broader push to shore up worker protections during and after the pandemic.[1]
Business groups and conservative legal organizations later seized on the proxy voting procedures as grounds to challenge the statute, arguing that the Constitution's Quorum Clause demands the physical presence of a majority of members in each chamber before any binding votes can take place.[1] Supporters of the law countered that the House has long set its own rules and that nothing in the Constitution explicitly forbids counting members who are not in the chamber, warning that unwinding pandemic-era votes could cast doubt on a wide array of measures adopted over those years.[1]
The Fifth Circuit majority sided with the challengers, reading the Quorum Clause to require that members be physically present to be counted and concluding that Congress had crossed a constitutional line when it allowed proxy votes to establish a quorum for passing the accommodations law.[1] Dissenting judges warned that the ruling could unsettle the settled understanding that each chamber of Congress decides its own procedures and accused the majority of inviting chaos by opening the door to retroactive attacks on pandemic-era legislation.[1]
For employers and workers in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi, the immediate question is practical: whether companies must keep offering schedule changes, lighter duties, remote work and other accommodations that many had begun providing under the federal law, and what recourse pregnant employees now have if those supports are withdrawn.[1] Legal experts expect a period of uncertainty while the Justice Department seeks emergency relief from the Supreme Court and businesses weigh the legal risk of rolling back benefits that have quickly become standard in many workplaces.[1]
Show source details & analysis (1 source)
📌 Key Facts
- On Friday, November 20, 2026, the Fifth Circuit ruled 9-8 that the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act was passed in violation of the Constitution’s Quorum Clause.
- The court held that proxy votes used during the Covid-19 pandemic cannot be counted toward the quorum required for Congress to conduct business.
- The decision effectively invalidates the law in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi, affecting workplace accommodations for an estimated 20 million women, and is expected to be appealed to the Supreme Court.
📰 Source Timeline (1)
Follow how coverage of this story developed over time