A summary of mainstream reporting, plus the facts and perspectives it leaves out. A more honest account of each story.
Back to all stories

Judge tosses Metro Surge case, flags perjury by immigration agents

A federal magistrate judge in Minnesota has thrown out a key Operation Metro Surge case from St. Cloud and urged a formal misconduct probe into two immigration agents he says likely lied under oath and filed a false affidavit.[1]

In a blistering ruling, U.S. Magistrate Judge Leo Brisbois found Border Patrol Agent Marco Antonio Muniz probably committed perjury about a vehicle pursuit and crash involving defendant Mohamed Abdirizak Jama, and said there is a reasonable basis to believe Homeland Security Investigations Agent Richard Berger engaged in misconduct by submitting a false sworn statement to justify Jama's arrest.[1] Brisbois concluded the agents had "no legal basis" to stop Jama's van because the registered owner was lawfully in the U.S., contradicting Berger's affidavit that a license-plate hit flagged someone who was undocumented and "armed and dangerous."[1]

Jama, a U.S. citizen, was arrested in St. Cloud in January during Operation Metro Surge and charged with assaulting Border Patrol agents with his vehicle, but those charges were recently dismissed after Brisbois suppressed the evidence stemming from the stop.[1] The judge said the case file was "littered with blatant contradictions," and his order refers the matter for potential investigation by federal authorities, highlighting what he described as systemic discovery failures and sworn statements that did not match video and other evidence.[1]

Questions about the case escalated when U.S. Attorney Daniel Rosen disclosed that Immigration and Customs Enforcement and Border Patrol either ignored or failed to satisfy at least 12 discovery requests for key evidence that defense lawyers were entitled to see.[1] In a filing responding to Brisbois, Rosen acknowledged the discovery problems but defended Berger and Muniz, arguing the judge's perjury findings were unsupported by the record, even as he moved to dismiss the charges against Jama.[1]

The St. Cloud arrest grew out of Operation Metro Surge, a Homeland Security effort that deployed Berger and other agents across Minnesota and relied heavily on Berger's sworn statements to secure charges in at least 25 cases.[1] FOX 9 reports that a different federal judge had already criticized Berger in an earlier, unrelated case, finding that he filed a "false affidavit" there as well, a pattern that now raises the stakes for any broader review of Metro Surge prosecutions that depended on his declarations.[1]

Brisbois's ruling and his call for a misconduct probe sharpen a growing clash between the bench and federal immigration agents over credibility and transparency, with one side pointing to repeated discovery lapses and conflicting stories, and prosecutors insisting they see no intentional wrongdoing by the agents they rely on.[1] The outcome could reverberate far beyond Jama's dismissed case, as defense attorneys now have fresh ammunition to challenge past and pending Operation Metro Surge cases that rest on Berger's word.[1]

  1. FOX 9
Legal Immigration & Civil Rights
Show source details & analysis (1 source)

📌 Key Facts

  • Defendant: U.S. citizen Mohamed Abdirizak Jama was arrested in January 2026 in St. Cloud during Operation Metro Surge and charged with assaulting Border Patrol agents with a vehicle; those charges were recently dismissed.
  • Judge Leo Brisbois found agents had “no legal basis” to stop Jama’s van because the registered owner was lawfully in the U.S., contradicting HSI Agent Richard Berger’s sworn claim that the plate hit on someone undocumented and “armed and dangerous.”
  • Brisbois wrote that the case file was “littered with blatant contradictions,” found probable cause that Border Patrol Agent Marco Antonio Muniz perjured himself about the pursuit and collision, and said there is a reasonable basis to believe Berger engaged in misconduct by filing a false affidavit.
  • U.S. Attorney Daniel Rosen revealed ICE and Border Patrol ignored or failed to satisfy at least 12 discovery requests for key evidence, but in his filing he defended Berger and Muniz and called the judge’s perjury finding unsupported.
  • FOX 9 notes that a different federal judge has already criticized Berger for a “false affidavit” in another case, and that Berger’s sworn statements were used in at least 25 Operation Metro Surge prosecutions in Minnesota.

📰 Source Timeline (1)

Follow how coverage of this story developed over time

November 19, 2026