A summary of mainstream reporting, plus the facts and perspectives it leaves out. A more honest account of each story.
Back to all stories

DOJ Appeals Ruling That Found Los Angeles U.S. Attorney Serving Illegally

The Justice Department asked the US Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit late Tuesday to halt a federal judge's ruling that found Los Angeles interim US attorney Bill Essayli is serving unlawfully and disqualified him from two criminal cases, escalating a high-stakes fight over the Trump administration's appointment of top federal prosecutors.[1]

In an emergency filing submitted hours after a lower court refused to pause its order, department lawyers said they would seek immediate relief to keep Essayli in place while the appeal proceeds, arguing that removing him now would disrupt ongoing prosecutions and undermine the administration's authority to staff US attorney offices.[1]

On Monday, November 16, Judge J. Michael Seabright, a federal judge sitting by designation in California, declined to stay his earlier decision that barred Essayli from participating in two criminal matters after finding that he was acting as US attorney in violation of federal appointment rules. The judge concluded that Essayli's designation ran afoul of statutory limits on interim US attorneys and the constitutional requirement that permanent top federal prosecutors either be confirmed by the Senate or appointed by local district judges.[1]

Essayli is one of several Trump-aligned prosecutors whose interim terms expired after 120 days in 2025, the maximum period allowed for an interim US attorney appointed by the attorney general; after that, the administration relabeled them as "first assistants" and kept them in charge of their districts without seeking Senate confirmation. Critics in Congress and the legal community say that maneuver effectively sidestepped the Senate's advice-and-consent role and turned what is supposed to be a temporary stopgap into a long-term workaround, while the administration has contended it is a lawful use of internal Justice Department succession rules.[1]

The battle over Essayli's status is unfolding as the Supreme Court weighs whether to step into parallel disputes involving Sigal Chattah, the acting US attorney in Nevada, and John A. Sarcone III, who has been serving as the top federal prosecutor in the Northern District of New York under the same rebranding strategy. If the justices agree to hear those cases, a ruling could effectively decide whether the administration's broader effort to keep Trump loyalists in US attorney posts without Senate approval passes legal muster, or whether district judges and the Senate must reassert their traditional role in filling those powerful law-enforcement positions.[1]

Legal analysts note that while presidents of both parties have relied on interim appointments to manage turnover in US attorney offices, the Trump administration's decision to extend that stopgap model by reclassifying expired interims as acting "first assistants" pushes into largely untested constitutional territory and raises the possibility that convictions secured under their supervision could face challenges if their appointments are ultimately struck down. The 9th Circuit's response to the Justice Department's emergency request, and any eventual Supreme Court action on the related Nevada and New York cases, will determine not just Essayli's future in Los Angeles but also how far presidents may go in bypassing Senate confirmation for some of the nation's most influential federal prosecutors.[1]

  1. New York Times
Courts & Justice Department Federal Appointments and Separation of Powers
Show source details & analysis (1 source)

📌 Key Facts

  • On Monday, November 16, 2026, Judge J. Michael Seabright refused to stay an earlier ruling disqualifying Bill Essayli from two criminal cases as unlawfully serving as U.S. attorney.
  • Late Tuesday, November 17, 2026, the Justice Department filed in the 9th Circuit saying it would seek emergency relief to keep Essayli in place.
  • Essayli is part of a group of Trump-aligned interim U.S. attorneys whose terms expired after 120 days in 2025; the administration then rebranded them as first assistants acting as top prosecutors without Senate confirmation.
  • The Supreme Court is already considering whether to take up parallel cases involving U.S. attorneys Sigal Chattah in Nevada and John A. Sarcone III in the Northern District of New York, and a decision there could resolve Essayli’s status.
  • Permanent U.S. attorney appointments ordinarily require Senate confirmation or appointment by district judges, making the administration’s workaround a significant test of executive power over federal prosecutors.

📰 Source Timeline (1)

Follow how coverage of this story developed over time

November 18, 2026