Federal Appeals Court Weighs Trump Bid To Shift Hush-Money Case
A federal appeals court panel in Manhattan heard more than an hour of arguments Monday on Donald Trump's attempt to move his New York hush-money case into federal court after his felony conviction, a maneuver that could upend his ongoing state appeal.[1]
At the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, Trump lawyer Robert Giuffra Jr. urged two of the three judges to immediately assert control over the case and order New York's Appellate Division to halt work on Trump's direct state appeal, arguing that the prosecution should never have proceeded in state court because the underlying conduct occurred while Trump was president.[1] Judges John M. Walker Jr. and Raymond J. Lohier Jr. pressed Giuffra on whether federal law allows a criminal case to be removed from state court after a jury verdict and a completed trial, and the panel did not issue a ruling from the bench.[1]
The federal appeal stems from U.S. District Judge Alvin Hellerstein's August 2026 decision, his third, rejecting Trump's bid to "remove" the prosecution from Manhattan state court under a statute that lets some federal officers shift state criminal cases into federal court.[1] Hellerstein had earlier ruled that Trump's alleged conduct in arranging and recording hush-money payments was not an official presidential act, and therefore did not qualify for that special removal protection, a conclusion Trump is now asking the 2nd Circuit to overturn.
Trump's legal push comes more than two years after a Manhattan jury convicted him in May 2024 on 34 counts of falsifying business records tied to a $130,000 payment to adult film actor Stormy Daniels during the 2016 campaign, which prosecutors said was part of a scheme to hide damaging information from voters.[1] He received no punishment at sentencing but is pursuing parallel challenges in state and federal courts aimed at wiping out the conviction altogether, a result that would remove the only criminal verdict currently on his record as he continues to loom over national politics.[1]
In the state system, Trump is pressing a traditional direct appeal that attacks the trial judge's legal rulings and the way prosecutors charged the case, while in federal court he is arguing that New York prosecutors never had authority to bring the case in the first place because it allegedly targeted conduct bound up with his duties as president.[1] The 2nd Circuit judges' questions Monday signaled concern that embracing Trump's theory of post-verdict removal could invite losing defendants to race to federal court after adverse state jury verdicts, potentially undercutting the balance between state and federal criminal systems.
How the 2nd Circuit rules will shape not only Trump's path to erasing the hush-money conviction but also the reach of the federal officer removal law for future prosecutions that touch on a president's private and public conduct. A decision in Trump's favor could pause or even sideline his state appeal while a federal judge re-examines whether Manhattan prosecutors had power to bring the case, while a loss would leave Trump to fight the conviction in New York's appellate courts with one less avenue of relief.[1]
Show source details & analysis (1 source)
📌 Key Facts
- On Monday, November 16, 2026, a 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals panel held over an hour of arguments on Trump’s request to transfer his New York hush-money case to federal court post-conviction.
- Trump lawyer Robert Giuffra Jr. asked the panel to immediately assert control over the case and stop New York’s Appellate Division from proceeding with Trump’s direct state appeal.
- Judges John M. Walker Jr. and Raymond J. Lohier Jr. expressed skepticism about whether federal law authorizes the post-verdict transfer procedure Trump is seeking, and the panel issued no immediate ruling.
- The federal appeal follows Judge Alvin Hellerstein’s August 2026 decision—his third—denying Trump’s effort to remove the hush-money prosecution from state to federal court.
- Trump was convicted in May 2024 on 34 counts of falsifying business records related to a $130,000 payment to Stormy Daniels; he received no punishment but is appealing to erase the conviction.
📰 Source Timeline (1)
Follow how coverage of this story developed over time