A summary of mainstream reporting, plus the facts and perspectives it leaves out. A more honest account of each story.
Back to all stories

St. Paul mayor formally denies police chief's harassment claims

St. Paul Mayor Kaohly Her formally filed a 68-page legal response on Monday denying Police Chief Axel Henry's accusations that she sexually harassed him, inappropriately touched him and then retaliated, and asked a Ramsey County judge to throw out his lawsuit.[1]

In the filing, Her and the City of St. Paul argue that the chief's claims mischaracterize political and policy disputes over issues like cooperation with federal immigration authorities, police oversight and budgeting as personal misconduct, and they urge the court to dismiss the case in its entirety.[1] Her's response specifically denies Henry's allegation that she called him a "MILF," rejects claims she made sexual innuendo about his penis, and disputes that any contact with his thigh was sexual in nature, while the city notes one witness reported a leg touch that an internal inquiry concluded was not sexual.[1] She also contests his description of a late-night bar meeting, saying his partner was invited, they met to discuss work, she drank only a nonalcoholic beverage, and she never offered him a ride home.[1]

Henry's lawsuit, filed earlier this year, portrays Her as blurring personal and professional boundaries and retaliating when he did not reciprocate alleged advances, including by undermining his authority and creating a hostile working environment. His complaint highlighted encounters he said took on a sexual tone, including comments about his body and a bar meeting he characterized as inappropriate, and framed his treatment as part of a broader struggle over his leadership of the department. Her's response flips that narrative, insisting their clashes are rooted in legitimate policy disagreements about how aggressively St. Paul police should cooperate with ICE, how civilian oversight should function, and how the city should allocate money to public safety.

The bar meeting offers one of the sharpest factual disputes. Henry alleges the mayor invited him out late, drank alcohol, initiated sexualized conversation and touched his leg in a way he perceived as inappropriate, but Her's filing stresses that she drank only a nonalcoholic drink, invited his partner, and that any brief leg contact observed by a witness was reviewed internally and found not to be sexual harassment.[1] The city's position is that the chief is retroactively recasting mundane or work-related interactions as harassment against the backdrop of friction over how the police department should respond to contentious issues like immigration enforcement and oversight.

The legal fight now leaves St. Paul with its two top public safety figures locked in open conflict, and the outcome could shape how much power the mayor's office has over policing and how future misconduct complaints by or against city leaders are handled. A judge will decide whether Henry's lawsuit survives Her's motion to dismiss and moves into discovery, which could force the release of internal emails, witness accounts and investigative files that go beyond what has so far surfaced in public court documents.

  1. FOX 9
Legal Local Government Public Safety
Show source details & analysis (1 source)

📌 Key Facts

  • Mayor Kaohly Her filed a 68-page response Monday denying Police Chief Axel Henry’s allegations of sexual harassment, inappropriate touching and retaliation.
  • Her and the City of St. Paul both ask the court to dismiss Henry’s lawsuit, framing their conflict as driven by disagreements over ICE, police oversight and budgeting.
  • Her denies specific claims including the alleged “MILF” remark, sexual innuendo about Henry’s penis, and sexual touching of his thigh, though the city acknowledges one witness reported a leg touch that an internal probe did not deem sexual.
  • Her disputes Henry’s account of a late-night bar meeting, saying his partner was invited, they met for work discussion, she consumed only a nonalcoholic drink, and she did not offer him a ride home.

📰 Source Timeline (1)

Follow how coverage of this story developed over time

November 17, 2026