ABC Asks Judge To Halt Early FCC License Reviews; Judge Weighs Jurisdiction And Free Speech
U.S. District Judge Loren AliKhan heard roughly two hours of arguments in Washington, D.C., on ABC's request to block the Federal Communications Commission's early license-review process on Tuesday, October 6, 2026.[1]
ABC told the court the April 2026 order is unconstitutional retaliation for disfavored content and is already chilling its coverage.[2] Attorney Beth Wilkinson said the order forces eight ABC-owned stations into an "unprecedented" early renewal and likened the situation to having ABC's "head on the guillotine." CBS News
The Justice Department countered that the FCC used early renewals to obtain information after ABC allegedly "refused to adequately respond" to an anti-discrimination probe into Disney's diversity, equity and inclusion practices.[2] DOJ lawyer Dimitar Georgiev-Remme also argued the district court lacks jurisdiction because Congress requires challenges to go first to the full FCC and then to a federal appeals court.[2]
FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr issued the April order shortly after a Jimmy Kimmel joke that angered President Trump.[1] ABC pointed to a July White House speech in which Trump scolded ABC and NBC and said their licenses should be revoked, calling that speech a "direct threat." CBS News ABC told the court the order is already altering editorial choices, citing changes on "The View" and Jimmy Kimmel posting a political interview to YouTube instead of airing it on ABC.[2]
Judge AliKhan did not rule from the bench and ordered additional briefing, with the government due to file by October 9 and ABC by October 14, 2026.[1] The case is one of several legal clashes between the Trump administration and media outlets that have raised similar First Amendment and jurisdictional questions.[1]
Show source details & analysis (3 sources)
📌 Key Facts
- U.S. District Judge Loren AliKhan presided over a roughly two-hour hearing on ABC's motion for a preliminary injunction against the FCC's early license reviews on October 6, 2026, in Washington, D.C. U.S. District Judge Loren AliKhan.
- ABC argued that the April 2026 early-renewal order is unconstitutional retaliation for disfavored content and already chills speech, with ABC attorney Beth Wilkinson likening the process to having the network's “head on the guillotine.” Beth Wilkinson.
- Wilkinson said the April order forces eight ABC-owned stations whose licenses were not due until 2028–2031 into an unprecedented early renewal process. eight ABC-owned stations.
- Wilkinson pointed to a July 2026 White House speech in which President Trump scolded ABC and NBC and called for their licenses to be revoked, calling that speech a “direct threat” to ABC. July 2026 White House speech.
- ABC told the court the early-review order is already altering editorial choices — citing changes in how The View selects political clips and Jimmy Kimmel posting an interview with a Democratic Senate candidate on YouTube instead of airing it on ABC. Jimmy Kimmel.
- The Justice Department told the court the FCC moved to impose early renewals because ABC allegedly “refused to adequately respond” to an ongoing anti-discrimination investigation into Disney's diversity, equity and inclusion practices and that early renewal was a tool to obtain needed information; DOJ also argued the district court lacks jurisdiction because challenges must first go to the full FCC and then to a federal appeals court. DOJ lawyer Dimitar Georgiev-Remme.
- Judge AliKhan did not rule from the bench and ordered additional briefing on the jurisdiction and First Amendment questions, with the government ordered to file by October 9, 2026, and ABC by October 14, 2026. additional briefing.
- PBS notes the early-renewal order was issued in April 2026 by FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr shortly after a Jimmy Kimmel joke angered President Trump, and the case is one of several legal clashes between the Trump administration and media outlets. FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr.
📰 Source Timeline (3)
Follow how coverage of this story developed over time
- On Tuesday, October 6, 2026, U.S. District Judge Loren AliKhan held a roughly two-hour hearing on ABC's motion for a preliminary injunction against the FCC's early license reviews.
- Judge AliKhan did not rule from the bench and instead ordered additional briefing, with the government to file by October 9 and ABC by October 14, 2026.
- DOJ attorney Dimitar Georgiev-Remmel argued the district court lacks jurisdiction because Congress requires challenges to go first through the FCC and then to an appellate court, and said ABC had not shown irreparable harm since its licenses remain valid.
- ABC lawyer Beth Wilkinson argued that the early-review order is unconstitutional retaliation for disfavored content and is already chilling editorial decisions ahead of the midterm elections, describing the process as like having ABC's 'head on the guillotine.'
- The article reiterates that FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr ordered the early renewals in April 2026 shortly after Jimmy Kimmel made a joke that angered President Trump, and notes this case is among several legal clashes between Trump's administration and media outlets.
- On Tuesday, October 6, 2026, Disney's ABC argued for roughly two hours before U.S. District Judge Loren AliKhan in Washington, D.C., asking her to block the FCC's early license-review process.
- ABC attorney Beth Wilkinson said comments by President Trump and FCC Chair Brendan Carr show the April 2026 early-renewal order was retaliation for ABC content that offended the administration.
- Wilkinson told the court the April order forces eight ABC-owned stations whose licenses were not due until 2028-2031 into an "unprecedented" early renewal process that she likened to waiting with "head on a guillotine."
- Wilkinson cited a July 2026 White House speech in which President Trump scolded ABC and NBC for not airing his remarks and called for their licenses to be revoked, calling it a "direct threat" to ABC.
- She argued the early-review process is already chilling coverage, pointing to changes in how "The View" selects political clips and to Jimmy Kimmel posting an interview with Texas Democratic Senate candidate James Talarico on YouTube instead of airing it on ABC.
- DOJ lawyer Dimitar Georgiev-Remme told the court the FCC acted because ABC allegedly "refused to adequately respond" to an ongoing anti-discrimination investigation into Disney's diversity, equity and inclusion practices, and that early renewal was a tool to obtain needed information.
- The October 6 arguments focused heavily on jurisdiction, with DOJ claiming that any challenge must go first to the full FCC and then to a federal appeals court, while ABC argued district-court intervention is necessary to stop ongoing First Amendment retaliation and harm.
- Wilkinson said even if ABC had appealed the April 2026 order within the FCC, the commission could have delayed indefinitely, and that later license renewal would not remedy chilled speech that already occurred.