Study Finds U.S. Murders Keep Falling Despite Spikes In Some Cities
The Council on Criminal Justice released a study on July 23, 2026, showing U.S. murders continued a historic decline nationwide even as some cities saw sharp spikes.[1]
The report analyzed crime trends in 36 U.S. cities for January-June 2026.[1] It found homicide rates fell in 21 of 30 surveyed cities, averaging an 18% drop in the first half of 2026 versus the same period in 2025.[1] The study says U.S. murders likely hit their lowest rate since 1900 in 2025, and that the downward trend continued into 2026.[1]
San Francisco's homicide rate rose 55% from early 2025, but analysts noted that increase came off a very low baseline.[1] Dallas and Salt Lake City recorded double-digit homicide increases, and Austin's murders rose 9% versus 2025 and 74% versus 2019.[1] Across 13 tracked offenses, nine crime types fell in early 2026, with carjackings dropping the most while reported drug offenses rose versus 2025 but remained below 2019 levels.[1]
The mainstream summary emphasizes a nationwide decline in homicides while acknowledging spikes in certain cities, but it does not address the criticism of progressive criminal justice reforms that some analysts argue may contribute to rising violent crime in specific locales like Chicago. Gianno Caldwell asserts that policies such as sanctuary-city rules and the elimination of cash bail are primarily responsible for increased violence, suggesting that the overall decline in murders does not validate these reforms but rather occurs 'in spite of' them. This perspective highlights a significant tension between local governance strategies and national crime trends that the mainstream account overlooks.
Furthermore, the mainstream coverage does not mention the effectiveness of federal enforcement operations, which Caldwell argues lead to rapid reductions in violent crime. He posits that local leaders who prioritize ideological concerns over public safety are failing their communities. This critique of local governance and its implications for crime rates adds a layer of complexity to the narrative of declining homicides that the mainstream summary fails to capture, suggesting that the solutions to crime may not be as straightforward as the data implies.[2]
Show source details & analysis (1 source)
📌 Key Facts
- On July 23, 2026, the Council on Criminal Justice released a study of crime trends in 36 U.S. cities covering January–June 2026.
- In 21 of 30 surveyed cities, homicide rates fell by an average of 18% in the first half of 2026 compared with the same period in 2025.
- The study says U.S. murders likely hit their lowest rate since 1900 in 2025, with the downward trend continuing into 2026.
- San Francisco’s homicide rate rose 55% from early 2025 off what analysts called a very low baseline, while Dallas and Salt Lake City also saw double-digit homicide increases and Austin’s murders rose 9% vs 2025 and 74% vs 2019.
- Across 13 tracked offenses, nine crime types fell in early 2026; carjackings dropped the most, while reported drug offenses rose compared with 2025 but remained below 2019 levels.
📊 Analysis & Commentary (1)
"Gianno Caldwell's opinion piece uses his brother's murder and recent Chicago homicide statistics to argue that sanctuary-city policies and elimination of cash bail are driving violent crime, praises federal marshals operations as effective remedies, and criticizes local progressive officials (whom he accuses of prioritizing ideology over victims) — a direct, law-and-order advocacy responding to broader reporting that national murder rates have fallen but some cities have spikes."
📰 Source Timeline (1)
Follow how coverage of this story developed over time