University Of Tennessee To Pay $1.9 Million To Fired Professor
On Monday, June 29, 2026, the University of Tennessee System Board of Trustees approved a $1.9 million settlement with former professor Tamar Shirinian, resolving her lawsuit over her firing.[1]
Shirinian was fired on February 11, 2026 after social media posts calling Charlie Kirk a "disgusting psychopath" and saying the world was better off without him following his September 10, 2025 assassination.[1] Chancellor Donde Plowman's termination letter said the posts celebrated a gruesome campus murder and demeaned the grief of Kirk's widow and children.[1] Shirinian will receive the settlement but will not be reinstated to her position.[1]
Charlie Kirk was shot and killed during an event at Utah Valley University on September 10, 2025. Days later, University of Tennessee assistant professor Tamar Shirinian posted in a private social media group that the world was better off without Kirk and called him a "disgusting psychopath." She was placed on administrative leave, faced termination proceedings, and sued the university in October 2025 alleging the firing violated her First Amendment rights.[1]
The payout has drawn both criticism and praise online and highlights the contested line between faculty speech and institutional discipline in the wake of a campus murder.
The mainstream summary does not mention the broader context of the backlash against social media comments related to Charlie Kirk's assassination, where over 600 individuals faced repercussions for their remarks. This includes at least 40 faculty, staff, and students in higher education who were terminated or suspended for comments deemed disrespectful following Kirk's death. Such statistics highlight a significant trend of institutional responses to speech, which the summary downplays by focusing solely on Shirinian's case. The settlement reflects a complex interplay between First Amendment rights and institutional discipline, a nuance not fully explored in the mainstream account.
Additionally, while the summary frames Shirinian's comments as celebrating a murder, some perspectives argue that her remarks were made in a private Facebook group and were not particularly vile, suggesting a potential overreach in the university's disciplinary actions. This viewpoint is echoed by social media users who see the settlement as a necessary affirmation of free speech rights, contrasting sharply with the mainstream portrayal that emphasizes the emotional fallout from her comments. The settlement's amount also raises questions about the implications for academic freedom and the ongoing decline in institutional autonomy in U.S. higher education, a trend that has accelerated since 2020 according to the Academic Freedom Index Update 2026.[2][3][4][5]
Show source details & analysis (1 source)
📊 Relevant Data
Over 600 Americans were fired, disciplined, investigated, suspended, or otherwise punished for social media comments about Charlie Kirk's assassination.
More than 600 people were fired or punished for posting about Charlie Kirk’s death — The Guardian
At least 40 higher education faculty, staff, and students were terminated, suspended, or expelled for commentary alleged as insufficiently respectful toward Kirk following his death.
Reprisals against commentators on the Charlie Kirk assassination — Wikipedia (citing Chronicle of Higher Education)
Austin Peay State University in Tennessee reinstated a professor fired for a social media post after Kirk's assassination and paid a $500,000 settlement.
Tennessee University Reinstates Professor Fired for Charlie Kirk Post and Settles for $500K — First Amendment Watch
📌 Key Facts
- On Monday, June 29, 2026, the University of Tennessee System Board of Trustees approved a $1.9 million settlement with former professor Tamar Shirinian.
- Shirinian was fired on February 11, 2026, after social media posts calling Charlie Kirk a "disgusting psychopath" and stating the world was better off without him following his September 10, 2025 assassination.
- Chancellor Donde Plowman’s termination letter cited the posts as celebrating a gruesome campus murder and demeaning the grief of Kirk’s widow and children.
- Shirinian will receive the settlement but will not be reinstated to her position at the university.
📰 Source Timeline (1)
Follow how coverage of this story developed over time