DNA Match Leads To Arrest In 1990 New Jersey Killing Of Lisa McBride
A man was arrested after DNA linked him to the 1990 killing of Lisa McBride in New Jersey. Authorities said the match tied him to biological evidence collected at the decades-old crime scene. Police announced the arrest this week and gave few immediate details about how investigators made the genetic connection.
The suspect has been previously linked to another case in which his wife vanished years ago, according to the reporting. Authorities described his past as deadly and said the arrest represents a major development for local investigators.
The case underscores how modern DNA methods can revive long-stalled investigations and bring new scrutiny to people once thought unrelated to violent crimes. Officials did not immediately release charges or a court date, and the investigation is ongoing.
đ Key Facts
- Suspect identified as 54-year-old Robert William McCaffrey Jr., arrested in Manteo, North Carolina and extradited to Sussex County, New Jersey
- Victim Lisa Marie McBride, 27, disappeared June 23, 1990 from her Highland Lakes home and her remains were found four months later in the Delaware Water Gap National Recreation Area
- McCaffrey is charged with murder, burglary, and kidnapping and pleaded not guilty; DNA profile from 2022 exhumation and reanalysis matched him in CODIS in 2026
- Detention hearing scheduled for April 27, 2026, with a tentative pre-indictment conference on May 18, 2026
đ° Source Timeline (1)
Follow how coverage of this story developed over time