NYC Pro‑Palestinian Activist Responds After Foiled Molotov Plot, Declines Broad Condemnation of Political Violence

Fox News reports that Palestinian‑American activist Nerdeen Kiswani, a leader of the New York group Within Our Lifetime, publicly addressed an alleged Molotov cocktail plot against her life that investigators say they foiled late last month. According to court filings, undercover investigators stopped 26‑year‑old Alexander Heifler after he allegedly built as many as 12 incendiary devices he intended to throw at Kiswani’s car and home. At a press event, Kiswani condemned what she called 'Zionist terrorist organizations' trying to assassinate their critics and said that 'victims of a genocide have the right to defend themselves,' but she refused to clearly condemn political violence across the board or spell out what she considers legitimate 'self‑defense.' The piece notes that Kiswani’s group has previously refused to denounce U.S.‑designated terror organizations and that the Anti‑Defamation League has accused Within Our Lifetime of explicit support for violence against Israeli civilians, while a pro‑Israel analyst argues she is rebranding terrorism as 'resistance.' The incident is feeding online fights over whether U.S. pro‑Palestinian movements are normalizing violence and over the risk of tit‑for‑tat attacks as rhetoric around Israel and Gaza hardens on U.S. streets.