Remains of Molly Miller and Colt Haynes Identified in Oklahoma 13 Years After Car Chase Disappearance
Authorities in southern Oklahoma have identified two sets of human remains found on Feb. 18, 2026 in rural Love County as those of Molly Miller, 17, and Colt Haynes, 21, who vanished after a July 7, 2013 police pursuit and crash. The pair were passengers in a car driven by James Con Nipp that fled officers in Carter County; friends later reported getting calls from them asking for water and a ride, saying they were lost, but they were never seen again and the abandoned vehicle was found in the woods two weeks later. The Chickasaw Lighthorse Police Department and the Bureau of Indian Affairs’ Missing and Murdered Unit located the remains during a search of more than 1,000 previously unsearched acres after new information and land access opened up, with Miller’s identification by the medical examiner confirmed March 31. Investigators have not released causes of death but say the probe into the circumstances is ongoing, and the local district attorney plans to present the case to a multi-county grand jury once the investigation is complete, signaling potential criminal charges. Relatives, including Miller’s cousin Misty Miller Howell, say the discovery brings some closure but fuels their belief that foul play was involved and their demand for accountability.
📌 Key Facts
- Molly Miller, 17, and Colt Haynes, 21, disappeared on July 7, 2013 after a police chase in Carter County, Oklahoma, and their car was later found crashed and abandoned in nearby Love County.
- Their remains were discovered on February 18, 2026 during a search of more than 1,000 acres in Love County led by the Chickasaw Lighthorse Police Department and the Bureau of Indian Affairs Missing and Murdered Unit, in an area not previously searched.
- The medical examiner identified Miller’s remains on March 31, 2026; investigators have not disclosed causes of death, and the local district attorney says the case will go to a multi-county grand jury for possible charges once the investigation concludes.
📊 Relevant Data
American Indian and Alaska Native women in the US experience murder rates up to 10 times higher than the national average for all women.
MMIW — Native Womens Wilderness — Native Womens Wilderness
As of January 2024, Oklahoma ranked second in the nation for missing Indigenous people, with 86 out of 840 reported cases nationwide.
Meet the Oklahoma woman fighting against the nation's 'silent crisis' of missing Indigenous people — The Oklahoman
American Indians and Alaska Natives make up about 2% of the US population but represent 10% of all missing persons cases.
Mmiw: Data Reports 2026 — WIFI Talents
Jurisdictional complexities between tribal, state, and federal authorities contribute to delays and gaps in investigating cases of missing and murdered Indigenous women in the US.
Delaying Justice: How Jurisdictional Gaps Fuel the Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women Crisis in the United States — Minnesota Journal of Law & Inequality
In 2022, the National Crime Information Center reported 5,487 cases of missing Native American women and girls in the United States.
The Disappearance of Native American Women in the U.S. — Human Rights Research
📰 Source Timeline (1)
Follow how coverage of this story developed over time