Lubbock Health Director Suggests Letting Measles "Run Through" Unvaccinated Communities, Drawing Expert Rebukes
Dr. Katherine Wells, director of the Lubbock Public Health Department in West Texas, has sparked backlash after suggesting on a March 2026 podcast that officials may need to "let [measles] run through" certain vaccine‑hesitant populations while focusing quarantines and isolation on the most vulnerable. Wells, who was previously praised for helping curb a regional measles outbreak that infected more than 700 people, hospitalized 99 and killed two children, argued that repeated school quarantines and the grind of persuading resistant parents raise social and educational costs that current guidance doesn’t fully address. Her comments were immediately criticized by fellow physicians, including podcast co‑host Dr. Mark Abdelmalek, who called the idea "almost like surrendering," and former CDC infectious‑disease leader Dr. Demetre Daskalakis, who told MS NOW that "that is what giving up in public health looks like" and warned against "expos[ing] a bunch of kids to measles." The dispute comes as a major measles outbreak grips South Carolina and new cases appear nationwide, reviving hard questions about how aggressively health departments should enforce vaccination and quarantine rules in communities deeply influenced by anti‑vaccine sentiment. Public‑health experts online are treating Wells’ remarks as an early test of whether resource‑strained local agencies will stick to traditional U.S. measles containment standards or begin normalizing de facto herd‑immunity experiments in pockets of refusal.
📌 Key Facts
- Dr. Katherine Wells, Lubbock Public Health Department director, said on the "Why Should I Trust You?" podcast that officials may need to "let [measles] run through" some vaccine‑hesitant populations.
- The prior West Texas measles outbreak in her region infected more than 700 people, hospitalized 99 and killed two otherwise healthy children, amid plunging child immunization rates.
- Former CDC infectious‑disease leader Dr. Demetre Daskalakis called Wells’ proposal "what giving up in public health looks like," insisting officials should not "throw [their] hands up" and allow kids to be exposed.
📊 Relevant Data
In 2024, the largest racial/ethnic groups in Lubbock, Texas, were White (49.6%), followed by Hispanic (36.6%) and Black (7.7%), with a median household income varying by group.
Lubbock Demographics | Current Texas Census Data — texas-demographics.com
Non-Hispanic White children had the highest childhood vaccination rate at 75.5% in 2023, compared to lower rates among other racial and ethnic groups, with data for children born 2016-2019 showing combined vaccine series coverage by age 24 months.
Childhood Vaccinations: Rates Vary By State, Ethnicity, Race — shadac.org
The 2025 West Texas measles outbreak primarily affected unvaccinated children aged 5-17 in Mennonite communities, with low vaccination levels linked to community-specific factors, resulting in over 760 confirmed cases.
Texas measles outbreak hardened Mennonites against vaccines — texastribune.org
In the US, measles vaccination rates show significant disparities by ethnicity and race, with a 2025 study noting gaps that contribute to outbreak risks in under-vaccinated populations.
New study finds significant disparities by ethnicity and race in measles vaccination rates — sph.umn.edu
For Latinx individuals in North Texas, COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy is associated with socioeconomic disparities and language barriers, with 21% expressing hesitancy in a 2025 study.
COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy among Latinx individuals in North Texas — tandfonline.com
📰 Source Timeline (1)
Follow how coverage of this story developed over time