DeSantis Signs Missy’s Law, Urges Impeachment of Judge Who Freed Convicted Sex Offender Before Alleged Child Murder
Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis used a Tuesday bill‑signing event to call on the Republican‑controlled Florida House to impeach Leon County Judge Tiffany Baker‑Carper, who allowed convicted sex offender Daniel Spencer to remain free on bond before sentencing; Spencer is now charged, along with Chloe Spencer, in the 2025 killing of his 5‑year‑old stepdaughter, Missy Mogle. DeSantis signed “Missy’s Law,” which requires judges to keep defendants convicted of specified dangerous crimes in custody pending sentencing, arguing that had the law been in place, Missy would still be alive and calling Baker‑Carper’s decision a "miscarriage of justice" and "dereliction of judicial duty." He emphasized that the Legislature has more than the two‑thirds majority needed to impeach and claimed some Democrats might join such a vote, framing impeachment as a necessary check on judges he says "benefit the criminal element." The governor also signed House Bill 1159 to increase penalties and expand offenses related to child sexual abuse material, positioning both measures as part of a broader law‑and‑order push to ensure "swift and meaningful consequences" for offenders. The case is already feeding national debates over judicial discretion, post‑conviction release, and political efforts to remove judges after high‑profile crimes by repeat offenders.
📌 Key Facts
- DeSantis publicly urged the Florida House to impeach Leon County Judge Tiffany Baker‑Carper for releasing convicted sex offender Daniel Spencer on bond before sentencing.
- Spencer, later charged along with Chloe Spencer, is accused of murdering his 5‑year‑old stepdaughter, Missy Mogle, in 2025; prosecutors are seeking the death penalty.
- DeSantis signed Missy’s Law, requiring judges to keep defendants convicted of dangerous crimes in custody pending sentencing, and also signed HB 1159 to strengthen penalties for child sexual abuse material offenses.
📊 Relevant Data
Sex offenders in the US have a recidivism rate of 13% for new sex crimes within 5 years post-release, which is lower than recidivism rates for other types of offenders.
In 2020, 55% of youth homicide victims in the US were Black, despite Black youth comprising about 14% of the youth population, resulting in a per capita homicide victimization rate for Black youth that is approximately 8 times higher than for White youth.
Youth homicide victims, 1980-2020 — Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention (OJJDP)
Increasing racial diversity among judges, including more Black judges, reduces the Black-White gap in incarceration probability by up to 7 percentage points in US district courts.
Can Racial Diversity among Judges Affect Sentencing Outcomes? — American Political Science Review
📰 Source Timeline (1)
Follow how coverage of this story developed over time