New York Prison Guard Tried for Inmate’s Fatal Beating During 2025 Strike

Former Mid-State Correctional Facility guard Jonah Levi is on trial in Utica, New York, charged with murder in the 2025 death of 22-year-old inmate Messiah Nantwi after what prosecutors describe as a group beating that delivered 69 separate blows. Special prosecutor William Fitzpatrick told jurors that eyewitnesses will testify Levi repeatedly stomped Nantwi’s head and that DNA from Nantwi was found on Levi’s boots, while Levi’s lawyer argues any force used was justified by Nantwi’s alleged aggression and drug use and did not cause his death. The March 1, 2025 incident occurred as New York’s prisons were struggling through a three‑week wildcat guard strike that forced deployment of National Guard troops, and a Guardsman testified Nantwi calmed down once backup arrived but was later beaten in his room after refusing handcuffs and biting a guard. Prosecutors also say officers falsely claimed to have recovered a homemade knife as part of a cover‑up, and prisoner‑rights advocates are tying this case to a separate fatal beating of Robert Brooks at a nearby prison as evidence of a broader culture of guard violence. The trial will test whether a New York jury is willing to criminally convict a corrections officer for on‑duty conduct in a chaotic prison environment and could influence ongoing debates over oversight, staffing, and use‑of‑force standards in U.S. prisons.