FBI, ICE and Pentagon Buy Americans’ Data Without Warrants as FISA 702 Fight Nears
An NPR deep dive details how federal agencies including the FBI, Defense Department and Immigration and Customs Enforcement are buying bulk commercial data—especially cell-phone location records—from data brokers to track people in the United States without first getting warrants, exploiting what advocates call a 'data broker loophole' around Fourth Amendment limits. The piece reports that roughly 130 civil-society groups sent Congress a new letter urging lawmakers to close that loophole as they race to reauthorize Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act before its April 20 expiration, warning of an 'unprecedented expansion of warrantless mass surveillance' that AI tools could 'supercharge.' At a Senate hearing last week, FBI Director Kash Patel refused Sen. Ron Wyden’s request to commit not to buy Americans’ location data, instead saying the bureau 'uses all tools' and purchases 'commercially available information' consistent with current law. The article adds that AI firm Anthropic’s CEO Dario Amodei has warned that government-purchased records, when combined with powerful models, can automatically assemble a comprehensive dossier on any person, a stance that has put the company in a public clash with the Pentagon over using its technology for domestic mass surveillance. The reporting underscores that even after past reforms barred bulk collection of Americans’ data, federal agencies have shifted to the open market to get similar information, and that the looming 702 debate may be the most realistic chance in years to regulate that practice.
📌 Key Facts
- About 130 civil-society organizations have just sent Congress a letter demanding closure of the 'data broker loophole' as part of the Section 702 FISA reauthorization due by April 20, 2026.
- At a Senate hearing last week, FBI Director Kash Patel declined to commit to stop buying Americans’ location data, confirming the FBI purchases 'commercially available information.'
- AI company Anthropic and CEO Dario Amodei have publicly warned that government-purchased data plus AI can generate mass, automated dossiers on individuals, a position that has fueled a high-profile dispute with the Pentagon over surveillance uses of Anthropic’s models.
📊 Relevant Data
Black and Latino communities are disproportionately affected by mass surveillance in the United States.
We study mass surveillance for social control, and we see Trump laying the groundwork to ‘contain’ people of color and immigrants — USC Dornsife
Black and Indigenous communities are arrested and incarcerated at disproportionately high rates compared to their percentage in the U.S. population, with Indigenous girls imprisoned at four times the rate of White girls and Black girls at more than twice the rate of White girls.
We study mass surveillance for social control, and we see Trump laying the groundwork to ‘contain’ people of color and immigrants — USC Dornsife
AI facial recognition technology has failure rates as high as 35 percent for Black faces.
When the algorithm is wrong: A new partnership calls out racism in AI systems — University of Toronto Arts & Science
The data broker industry was valued at $270.40 billion in 2024 and is expected to reach $473.35 billion by 2032.
The data broker surveillance economy and the path forward — Vermont Daily Chronicle
📰 Source Timeline (1)
Follow how coverage of this story developed over time