MPD chief grilled over passivity during ICE Metro Surge
At a Monday meeting of the Minneapolis Community Commission on Police Oversight, Police Chief Brian O’Hara faced pointed criticism from roughly three dozen residents and activists who say MPD failed to protect people during DHS’s Operation Metro Surge and in the federal killings of Alex Pretti and Renee Good. Speakers from groups including the Twin Cities Coalition for Justice and Communities United Against Police Brutality accused officers of hanging back while heavily armed federal teams swept neighborhoods, with one resident saying, "We showed up. Where were you guys?" O’Hara defended his department by arguing that federal agents operate under different laws and that MPD has limited authority to interfere with what Washington labels lawful immigration enforcement, conceding the department “wasn’t perfect” and was in a “constant state of trying to adjust.” He also disclosed that MPD has opened two potential misdemeanor assault cases involving federal agents and referred them to an Inspector General’s Office, but said the department has received no response so far. The clash underscores a widening accountability gap: metro residents can grill their own chief in public, but any effort to hold federal officers to even misdemeanor standards is now stuck in a federal bureaucracy that doesn’t feel obliged to answer to Minneapolis.
📌 Key Facts
- Chief Brian O’Hara was questioned at a Community Commission on Police Oversight meeting in Minneapolis, with about three dozen people attending and voicing anger over MPD’s role during Operation Metro Surge.
- O’Hara said MPD’s ability to intervene was limited because federal agents operate under different laws, calling the department’s 2025 response a 'constant state of trying to adjust' and 'not perfect.'
- MPD has identified and referred two possible misdemeanor assault cases involving federal agents to an Inspector General’s Office, but has yet to receive any response on those referrals.
📊 Relevant Data
Operation Metro Surge, launched in December 2025, resulted in the arrest of more than 4,000 illegal aliens in Minnesota, including violent criminals such as murderers, sex offenders, and gang members.
DHS Reaches More than 4000 Arrests of Illegal Aliens Including Murderers, Sex Offenders, and Gang Members During Operation Metro Surge — Department of Homeland Security
In Minneapolis, approximately 60,300 immigrants reside, constituting 14% of the city's population, while Minnesota's overall immigrant population is 495,000, or 9% of the state's population.
Minneapolis, Minnesota - Immigrant population — Vera Institute
The growth of the Somali population in Minnesota is primarily due to refugee resettlement programs starting in the early 1990s following the Somali civil war, with Minnesota hosting the largest Somali community in the U.S.
How Minnesota became a hub for Somali immigrants in the U.S. — NPR
Somali immigrants in Minnesota commit certain crimes at higher rates than natives, with per capita rates showing overrepresentation in fraud and violent crimes, though overall immigrant crime rates are lower than natives nationally.
Yes, Somali Immigrants Commit More Crime Than Natives — City Journal
Operation Metro Surge caused an estimated $203.1 million economic impact in Minneapolis in one month, including $106.1 million in lost wages in the Twin Cities area due to disruptions in immigrant-dependent industries.
Measuring the economic damage of Minnesota's ICE surge is hard — Minnesota Reformer
From 2020 to 2024, immigration accounted for 94% of Minnesota's net population growth, contributing to labor force expansion but also pressuring housing and wages in low-skill sectors.
New Americans Drive Minnesota's Population Growth and Labor Force — Minnesota Women's Press
📰 Source Timeline (1)
Follow how coverage of this story developed over time